1970 Karen Wiedman Brabham
1971 Claudia Shiner Mize
1972 Cheryl Nicholson
1973 Karen Swanson Belanger
1974 Krissy Bragg Brown
1975 Patsy West
1976 Tika Bragg
1977 Debbie Mullany Deputy
1978 Cindy Glover
1979 Debbie Glore
1980 Susan Galeano Burton
1981 Patty Sanders
1982 Michelle Ripple
1983 Tina Osceola
1984 Tina Osceola
1985 Melissa Snyder
1986 Becky Brown Russakis
1987 Shanan Lang
1988 Becky Brown Russakis
1989 Jennifer Eng
1990 Michelle Hebden
1991 Wendy Armstrong Cooper
1992 Kara Davis
1993 Kara Davis
1994 Kathleen Clancy Wonnell
1995 Kristina Wiedman
1996 Jamie Witmer Pickett
1997 Nikki Tucker Mattick
1998 Shasta Bell
1999 Nikki Tucker Mattick
2000 Kimberly Rogers
2001 Carri Jones
2002 Autumn Phillips Perry
2003 Danielle Wiedman
2004 Ashley Furman
2005 Teresa Brabham
2006 Katie Greeley
2007 Brianna Norman
2008 Jenna Decker
2009 Mandi Tate
2010 Brianna Norman
2011 Brittany Newburn
2012 Savannah Krevitz
2013 Taylor Leikala
2014 Savannah Krevitz
2015 Jadelyn Bruce
2016 Ashley Graham
2017 Ashley Graham
2018 Jadelyn Bruce
2019/2020 Marie Luciano-Sileo
2021 Maria Luciano-Sileo
2022 Freda Mesekee